TOLEDO – Ahead of the Nov. 3 election, Toledo Firefighters Local 92 President Joe Cira addressed Toledo City Council at the end of a Finance, Debt & Budget Oversight Committee meeting on Wednesday, Oct. 28, and he indicated that the Toledo Fire & Rescue Department would be in dire straits without the passage of Issue 16.
Toledo Fire & Rescue crisis
“We need to discuss the crisis that the Toledo Fire is facing in terms of stations, apparatus, and staffing today,” Cira said after encouraging citizens to vote yes on Issue 16.
Cira said that even with the passage of Issue 16, the Fire Department faced a reduction in staffing, but approximately 40 positions between police and fire would be cut without Issue 16.
“My message today is simple: there is no fat to trim from Toledo Fire, but we need Issue 16 to address the current issues we have,” he said, and explained the extremely tenuous line the fire department was walking with their limited resources.
“As I stand here, one of the ambulances in West Toledo is out of service. If an ambulance breaks down right now or gets into an accident, there is no backup for it. We’ll be running with two less ambulances than what we need,” Cira said.
Similarly, Cira talked about the same margin of error they were dealing with for their fire engines. Engine 25 was in an accident last month.
“Our mechanics were able to work late into the night to get that engine back in service, but while it was down, there was no backup for it.”
From the 1980s until now, the call volume has increased three to four times with only an increase of ten extra personnel, Cira said.
“As population has went down, our run volume has continued to increase,” he said, and At-Large Councilman and Committee Chair George Sarantou asked for clarification on the nature of the bulk of the calls Fire & Rescue receives.
“80 to 90 percent of our calls are for medical; the remainder are for emergency and fire response,” Cira said. “We need Issue 16 to address the current issues we have.”

Issue 16, 2027 and beyond
Two separate plans were laid out before Council: one assuming the passage of Issue 16, and the other if Issue 16 did not pass.
Deputy Mayor Abby Arnold and Deputy Finance Director Melanie Campbell presented both paths and what the city’s finances would be like for each outcome.
Either way, Arnold said, difficult decisions would need to be made going forward.
In the event that Issue 16 passes: “For 2027, that reflects $20 million in additional income taxes…that grows to $25 million in [20]28 and 2029,” Campbell said.
“As you look at the financial projection on the fund balance, you’ll see that the financial outlook shows less reliance on the fund balance. However, it does show a decrease, overall, in the fund balance.”
Structurally, the General Fund faces sharp deficits with or without Issue 16 funds, with “the potential to face a negative fund balance by the end of 2029” if the Issue doesn’t pass, she said.
Issue 16 passage:
- $5.4 million to:
- Maintain and grow Police and Fire
- Increase size of Fire Investigation Unit
- Establish Residential Speed Enforcement Program, for use in neighborhoods only
- $5 million to prevent layoffs of Police and Fire
- $875,000 Maintain Vibrancy Initiative (including Legacy Corridor Program)
- $1.5 million maintain demolition funding
- $1.5 million maintain Violence Intervention Program
- $2.2 million maintain youth programming, events and pools
- $2.9 million maintain Blight Removal Services
- $4 million Fund Capital Project by reducing CIP transfer
- $1,625,000 to reduce reliance on fund balance
If Issue 16 doesn’t pass:
- No Police and/or Fire classes
- Reduce Fire Investigation Unit
- No Residential Speed Enforcement Program
- Reduce Gang Task Force
- Layoff Police and Fire
- Eliminate Vibrancy Initiative
- Demolition funding will only be for fire emergencies
- There will be no Violence Intervention Program
- Eliminate youth programming, events and close pools
- Reduce Blight Removal Services
- Reduce Capital Projects by keep CIP transfer at $24 million
- Additional layoffs
Arnold expanded on the list
“In the first scenario…we’re able to bring on new police officers and firefighters with classes of 40 each,” Arnold said. “We’d be adding 10 officers to the gang task force and expanding our Fire Investigative Unit.”
“$4 million available for capital projects by reducing that transfer from $24 million to $20, and that would allow us to spend $4 million dollars [more] on capital projects such as police and fire vehicles and equipment.”
One of the main differences, is that by 2029 the fund balance deficit would only be $1.7 million with $17 million left in the fund, whereas without Issue 16’s passage, it is projected to be at a $9,365,994 deficit with $3.5 million in debt by 2029.
Some of the hard decisions Arnold mentioned included “targeting a 5 percent reduction in contractual services,” by renegotiating contracts “to do the things that we do, less expensive.”
Eliminating vacancies in the government and consolidating leadership positions was projected to save $1 million. Reducing costs and increasing fees, was a general item thrown out by Arnold.
Repeatedly, Arnold said the administration was committed to these changes regardless of the results of the ballot initiative.
Without Issue 16, “right now, this working budget contemplates approximately 73 layoffs. Those are currently filled positions, not vacancies, with roughly half of those coming from our police and fire departments,” Arnold said. Youth programming would be gone, nuisance mowing would be gone, public swimming pools would not open, three blight crews would be reduced to one and curbside recycling might no longer exist for Toledo residents.
“The financial reality is that without the additional revenue, we simply cannot continue to provide the same level of service we do today,” Arnold said.
Further Issue 16 concerns
Eliminating curbside recycling caught Sarantou’s ear, and he inquired further. Arnold said the administration was contemplating its removal, and eliminating curbside recycling would save roughly $1.5 million a year for the city.
Healthcare for the city is also under negotiations, and Williams and Arnold talked about the possibility of creating savings through a potentially higher “copay” in the healthcare plan to save some of the layoffs.
Williams was interested in the changes to the Gang Taskforce, but Arnold was unsure of the cuts to the program. If the ballot measure passed, the 15-person Taskforce would expand by ten people.
A noticeably frustrated Mac Driscoll, at-large, said, “I understand this is not a finished product, but I’m looking at the expenditures in both scenarios, and I don’t…I see an effort, but I don’t see that the administration has fully satisfied what Council asked for in reducing expenditures by $10 million year-over-year.”
“In the Issue 16 passes scenario, we would be reducing our reliance on the General Fund by $10 million dollars,” Arnold said.
“But not lowering expenditures,” Driscoll said.
“We are absolutely lowering expenditures, but not to the same level that we would be in [if] Issue 16 doesn’t [pass],” she answered.
“You saw it as a charge to reduce the transfer, not necessarily as a charge to reduce expenditures. Is that correct?” Driscoll asked.
“We are meeting the $10 million through the reduction in the reliance on the fund balance in that category,” said Arnold.
At that, Driscoll ended his inquiry.

2026 on course with concerns in auto industry
Before the heated back-and-forth between Driscoll and Arnold, or Cira’s heartfelt plea for assistance, roughly a hundred people were present to observe the meeting, but also present was a pin-drop silence that hung in the air along with potential layoffs ahead of the city.
The Department of Finance reported figures through the end of September, and projected what would happen in the next two months.
For the most part, 2026 seemed to be on track for where it should be with the exception of income taxes for businesses, which had a 31.2 percent decrease between 2025 to 2026.
“The auto industry is the one that concerns us the most of being down,” said Jay Zawisza, the commissioner of taxation for the City of Toledo.
That 31.2 percent downturn was a difference of over $7 million. “Some of those numbers we can tie to one-time events,” he said. “Some of those we’re going to have to still see how those companies respond over these next couple of months, because if those would continue, that could easily affect those numbers the rest of the year.”
One suggested cause for the downturn in business taxation was “retooling” in the auto-industry, a claim Sarantou added a bit more background to.
“Supplier parts are going to slow down for a while, because they’re not building automobiles and trucks,” Sarantou said. “They’re basically retooling to prepare for the next models.”
ARPA
97.3 percent of the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds have been committed, which all of them need to be spent by the end of 2026.
Wage theft
Wage theft investigations were up, as expected, as the city advertised this facet of the government more openly.
“So far, we’ve processed cases for 39 workers, recovering just shy of $40,000 for them,” said Dan Morey, the commissioner of wage and hour compliance. “The average amount of unpaid wages was $1,011.”

Department of Public Utilities
Patekka Pope Bannister, the director of the City of Toledo Department of Public Utilities, reported mainly on the department’s successful efforts to recover owed utilities.
Sarantou commended Bannister on the department’s work. “I believe we started with about $61 million of debt, and at this point we’re down to about $38 million?”
Bannister confirmed, and Sarantou said, “I think that’s really good progress.”
Call for better communication
Prior to Cira’s comment during the meeting, Richard Arnold, a frequenter of Toledo and Lucas County government meetings, criticized city council for canceling Public Safety & Criminal Justice Reform Committee meetings.
“The comments that I’m about to make, I would have made at the November the 5th Safety Committee, but it’s been canceled,” he said.
“That’s the fourth one this year,” Arnold stressed, and read of the dates: Feb. 3, March 19, Nov. 19 and now Nov. 4.
“Even when you have safety committees, you don’t always advertise them to the public. I know you had one in June, and I checked over and over and over. It was not on the calendars,” he said. It should be noted, one of June’s committee meetings involved a discussion of Flock Group, Inc.’s automated license plate reader (ALPR) cameras, on June 22. The other committee meeting was on June 4.
In total, there have been eight Public Safety & Criminal Justice Reform Committee meetings so far this year, but the chair of that committee, John Hobbs III, councilman for District 1, was not present for the Finance, Debt & Budget Oversight Committee.
“City Council needs to do a better job scheduling and giving advanced notice of public safety committees,” he said, adding that this improvement was necessary even though unhappy people may show up to the meetings. “That’s the way it is.”
Next, Arnold was worried about the $91,661 eliminated from the Fire & Rescue’s budget for dive and hazmat team physicals. Arnold said someone had told him that other funds could cover this line item, but he wanted to ask on the record, “Does the fire department have sufficient funds to cover the more than $91,000 cut from their budget for dive and hazmat team physicals?”
There was no answer that day.











