WHITEHOUSE – The Village of Whitehouse is awaiting a final order from a Lucas County Common Pleas Court judge on a lawsuit filed by the contractor who installed a sewer line along the Wabash Cannonball Trail.
During the Nov. 17 Whitehouse Village Council meeting, Mayor Rich Bingham asked Law Director Kevin Heban to provide an update on that litigation, citing a desire to be transparent with citizens.
In 2019, council agreed to replace 6,300 linear feet of the 24-inch force main sewer line that transfers effluent from the west side of town to the east.
“The village, because of a number of complaints about the smell, decided to remove the existing force main and install a gravity sewer system,” Heban said.
With force main sewers, the effluent sits for unusually long detention times, causing hydrogen sulfide gas to form, which creates a rotten egg smell. With a gravity sewer, the sewage is always moving and does not have the opportunity for hydrogen sulfide gas to form.
After engineering was complete and easements purchased from four property owners, the village went out to bid in late 2020 and Mark Schaffer Excavating was awarded the project at a cost of $2,486,186.
Schaffer began the work in March 2021, with Jones & Henry overseeing the work on behalf of the village.
“During the project, a number of issues arose,” Heban said, explaining that in addition to a nationwide PVC shortage, the contractor found more issues in the force main because of the age of the pipes. Plus, the weather in the summer and fall was not conducive to a lot of work getting done, Heban added.
The work was completed in summer 2023, but in the process, Schaffer presented the village with a change order, seeking more funds, because of delays and increased costs. The village did not agree with the change order as presented. So the company filed a lawsuit against the village, and the two parties entered mediation.
That was unsuccessful, and Schaffer dismissed the litigation. But then Schaffer subsequently refiled the litigation. That went to a hearing in front of Judge Joe McNamara on Sept. 18, and McNamara found that a number of claims were justified. No final order has been issued, and it’s currently under reconsideration by the judge, Heban said. When a final order is released, Heban will meet with council and provide a recommendation.
“Generally, with pending litigation, we ask our clients not to comment but this is to keep council informed of the status and the present litigation,” he added.
During the meeting, council also:
-Held a first reading on approving a 4.2 percent cost of living increase for employees, based on inflation numbers, and one-time merit service payments based on years of service.
-Heard that village offices will be closed Nov. 26 and 27 for the Thanksgiving holiday.
-Encouraged residents to donate new, unwrapped toys to one of the Whitehouse donation boxes in village hall and at the fire station, as the village competes with Waterville to see who can donate the most toys for children in need.

-Held a first reading on rezoning the 6.6-acre parcel of village-owned property at Finzel and S.R. 64 from from C-3 General Commercial to C-4 Highway Commercial. The Toledo-Lucas County Public Library (TLCPL) has signed an agreement to purchase the property for $620,000, pending the successful rezoning of the land, in order to build a new Whitehouse Branch.
-Discussed the Nov. 5 filing of a petitions for a charter amendment to limit data centers to 10 megawatts. Leslie Harper, a Whitehouse resident who was among those gathering signatures for the petition, asked the village for an update. Heban said the petitions were forwarded to the Lucas County Board of Elections, which is still dealing with the Nov. 3 election.
Once the village learns that enough signatures have been validated, it will move forward with plans for a special election – as the village is required to put the matter to a vote between 60 and 120 days after receiving notice. Monclova Township resident Lyn Cox said the petitions were also presented to Waterville the next day, and her hope is that the village and city could split the cost of having a special election. Council Member Carrie Tuohy asked Heban what his guess is on the cost, and he estimates about $15,000 to host a special election. Harper also asked whether the village could enact a moratorium in the meantime, but Heban said he “has serious legal questions about whether a moratorium is legal.”





