In January, Ohio will send three new Democrats to Congress

When partisan gerrymandering has the opposite of its intended effect, you may hear pundits evoke the term “dummymander,” which has its roots in academia, and refers to a partisanly drawn map that ends up backfiring on the party that produced it. One way this occurs is when a party carves up regions where its support is strongest in order to spread those voters across multiple districts. This is done to dilute the influence of voters who tend to support the opposing party.

However, it’s a maneuver that comes with risk: A strong enough wave year for the opposing party, a drastic shift among otherwise reliable voting blocs, or a combination of the two, can push some of those districts into competitive territory — which is exactly what cost some GOP incumbents their seats last week.

In Ohio, a couple of districts with mostly rural geography saw strong turnout in their urban cores, which — combined with a national swing left — helped Democrats hold onto, and even flip, some of the state’s congressional seats.

Ohio sends a delegation of 15 to the U.S. House of Representatives. Of those 15 lawmakers, 10 are Republicans and five are Democrats. Each represents a district of over 700,000 people. The boundaries of these districts are drawn to be roughly balanced in their population and are updated to reflect the state’s population changes — but that doesn’t guarantee balance in political representation — as Ohio was recently ranked the 7th most gerrymandered state in the country.

To simplify what can seem convoluted, the drawing of House districts, a process known as redistricting, is carried out by the Ohio Redistricting Commission on which the governor and other elected officials sit. Because it’s Republicans who hold all of the statewide offices, the party has a majority on the commission, and thus, greater leverage. Now, if the commission fails to reach a bipartisan consensus on legislative maps, meaning there’s agreement from Democratic members, the state legislature must step in to draw up new maps.

Last year, the ultimatum before Dems on the commission was to hand Republicans a greater advantage in two Democratic districts — or risk the loss of both — in a hypothetical, far more extreme gerrymander that could have been drawn by the Statehouse’s Republican supermajority.

Wanting to avoid handing GOP lawmakers a blank canvas, they chose the first path, favoring an agreement with Republicans on the commission, whose proposal made the state’s 1st and 9th congressional districts — represented by Greg Lansman (D-Cincinnati) and Marcy Kaptur (D-Toledo), respectively — even more competitive than they already were. This was done by swapping out some Democratic suburbs and exurbs for more rural areas, an arrangement Republicans thought, based on how these constituencies tend to vote, would help them flip both seats. However, that’s not at all what happened on Tuesday.

Instead of the state’s U.S. House delegation, currently composed of 10 Republicans and five Democrats, becoming one made up of 12 Republicans and just three Democrats, an unanticipated outcome would result. In addition to Kaptur and Landsman surviving the modifications to their district lines, Democrats flipped two Republican-held seats, amid a surge in urban turnout.

(Wikimedia / OpenStreetMap / Jaden Jefferson / TFP)
Democrat Don Leonard and incumbent Rep. Mike Carey (R-Columbus), candidates in Ohio’s 15th Congressional District race.

In Ohio’s 15th Congressional District, Democrat Don Leonard defeated Republican incumbent Mike Carey. A key source of Leonard’s support was the Franklin County portion of OH-15, a corner of the district that strongly favors Democrats and — because of this year’s blue wave — was enough to offset Carey’s strong rural support.

(Wikimedia / OpenStreetMap / Jaden Jefferson / TFP)
Democrat Kristina Knickerbocker and incumbent Rep. Mike Turner (R-Dayton), candidates in Ohio’s 10th Congressional District race.

In the 10th Congressional District, which is anchored by the city of Dayton, Democrat Kristina Knickerbocker pulled off a narrow defeat over incumbent Republican Mike Turner. As was the case with Leonard’s victory in Central Ohio, a combination of strong urban turnout and national headwinds helped to carry Knickerbocker over the finish line.

Those are two districts that, despite being drawn to favor Republicans, flipped regardless. However, there’s another that Dems managed to win, which — whether intentionally or not — has a composition favorable to Republicans. 

(Wikimedia / OpenStreetMap / Jaden Jefferson / TFP)
Democrat Brian Poindexter and incumbent Rep. Max Miller (R-Rocky River), candidates in Ohio’s 7th Congressional District race.

That would be the 7th Congressional District, represented by Congressman Max Miller (R-Rocky River). Stretching from the Cleveland suburbs down through Medina and Holmes counties, the 7th was going to be a heavy lift for Dems, arguably, even in a blue year. However, abuse allegations by Miller’s former spouse, who is also the daughter of Ohio Sen. Bernie Moreno (R), overshadowed his reelection bid and boosted the first–time campaign of Democrat Brian Poindexter, whose campaign centered around a working class message. Miller, who has denied the allegations against him, would lose to Poindexter by nearly 10 percentage points.

With these three flips, the makeup of the Buckeye State’s congressional delegation goes from 10R-5D to 8D-75 — an outcome that even the best of election forecasters had not expected. Kaptur’s showing in northwest Ohio was particularly strong. Her margin of victory was greater than it was in 2024, when she won by a plurality, under district lines that were actually less Republican-leaning than they were on election night.

Jaden Jefferson
Jaden Jefferson
Jaden Jefferson is a freelance political journalist for the Toledo Free Press. To check out more of his reporting, you can follow him on X (formerly Twitter), Facebook, Instagram, Threads, and Bluesky. He also has a YouTube channel, Jaden Jefferson Reports.

Related Articles

 

Stay Connected

6,978FansLike
1,921FollowersFollow
8,952FollowersFollow
98SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles