Planning for Braden Church building passes City Council

TOLEDO – Tuesday’s sparsely attended Housing, Community Development and Public Health Policy Committee meeting was about the possibilities for the boarded up and abandoned 35,581-square-foot historic church building at 2017 Lawrence Ave. (the Braden Church building).

Braden Church building. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

Built in 1923, the former Braden Church building was a symbolic anchor of the Englewood neighborhood, and the 2012 abandonment of the property by the Richard’s Temple of Deliverance congregation speaks to the difficulties and disinvestment in the Englewood community. 

Artspace preliminary feasibility 

The preliminary feasibility study done by the Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD) outlined, “In spring of 2026, the DHCD utilized nuisance abatement funds to secure the property to prevent further damage and preserve its potential for future redevelopment.”

In May of last year, Rosalyn Clemens, the chief of Housing and Neighborhood Sustainability, said their department put out a bid for proposals for the church building with Artspace Consulting out of Minneapolis, Minn., which won the bid in July 2025. 

The $35,000 contract awarded to Artspace was funded through a Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) planning fund.

After a community engagement initiative, Artspace found Englewood residents wanted to use the church building for a community gathering space, small business offices and art spaces.

A mostly unattended Housing, Community Development and Public Health Committee meeting for the City of Toledo at 1 Government Center inside City Council Chambers at 2 P.M. in Toledo, Ohio on Tuesday November 17, 2026. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

Two projects

Two tracks were presented, the first involving $18.4 million to redevelop the church building, and the second track involving an affordable housing initiative in the parking lot adjacent to the church building for $20.6 million. 

Clemens mentioned that the first track would be funded with “historic preservation tax credits and other funding sources,” with the second track funded by “low-income housing tax credits and other funding sources.”

Track One: Church Redevelopment (Historic Rehab + Mixed-Use Program): 26 affordable studio apartment units 750-900 square feet with common community space. 

Cost: $18.4 million

Mechanisms:  

  • $5.1 million Federal + Ohio Historic Tax Credits
  • $3.3 million New Market Tax Credit Equity
  • $3.5 million CDBG Section 105 Loan
  • $3.0 million Senior loan supported by operations
Braden Church building (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

Track Two: Affordable Housing Development 58-Unit LIHTC Mid Rise (Parking Lot adjacent to the Church)

Cost: $20.6 million (356K per unit)

Mechanisms:

  • $12.47M LIHTC investor Equity
  • $5M Permanent First Mortgage
  • $750K HOME Funds
  • $957K OHFA soft financing
  • $1.45M Sponsor Loan + deferred developer fee

Vanice Williams, president of Council and councilwoman for District 4 (where the church building is located), had previously recommended the discussion of the project around the building to iron out the details. 

Williams said she was “very supportive of the church project. I just don’t want us to get into having to hold this building and do nothing with it” and cast doubt on the parcels as viable for housing. 

“I probably need to be sold on the housing because I think the price will be a little bit higher than what we see here,” she said. 

The committee was held in relation to Ordinance 476-26, which allows DHCD to acquire parcels 2017 and 2013 on Lawrence Avenue. From there, DHCD will begin the application preparation, so they will be able to apply for the Ohio Preservation Tax Credit Round 38 by the end of March 2027. DHCD will know by the end of 2027 if they are awarded the credit funds. 

Clemens, in light of the push back and wanting to get the project rolling said, “Our priority would be to start with the church.”

Transfer of the property

The President and CEO of the Lucas County Land Bank was one of the few people present in the audience of the committee meeting and explained how the transfer of the property would take place if the ordinance passed. 

David Mann, the president and CEO of the Lucas County Land Bank, speaks about the process of transferring the Braden Church building to the city. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

“To be clear, we are not the owners of this church,” he said on behalf of the Land Bank. “The property is forfeited land, meaning that it has gone through tax foreclosure and has not yet been purchased at any of the share sales or prior forfeited land sales that have been offered.”

In light of the massive amount of delinquent taxes that would need to be paid to acquire the property – $440,158.24 – Council and DHCD did not expect a buyer at the forfeiture auction. 

After the auction reveals no buyer, “we will be charged $1 from the county auditor to acquire this property, and we will transfer to the city for $0. So that will be the financial implications for you right out of the gate,” Mann said. 

The low-to-no-cost to the government allowed the ordinance to receive support from Council and for DHCD to move to the application preparation stage for the project. 

Public comment

Only two members of the public gave comments. 

“I’m just looking forward to movement,” said Reggie Williams, a community member of Englewood and executive director of Marketplace for All People. “I’m thinking that a Black bookstore would be beneficial in that place,” he said of the church building, and recommended the sanctuary for use in neutral/nonreligious performances and events. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

“I’m just looking forward to movement,” said Reggie Williams, a community member of Englewood and executive director of Marketplace for All People. “I’m thinking that a Black bookstore would be beneficial in that place,” he said, and recommended the sanctuary for use in neutral/nonreligious performances and events.

Crystal Taylor, the executive director for Hope Connections, expressed support for the project as well, but said she had “some reservations.”

Crystal Taylor, the executive director for Hope Connections, expressed support for the Braden church project as well, but said she had “some reservations.” (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

“The change in housing and the tax liability that’s going to come on the residents that currently live there,” she said, could become a problem for current residents who are already burdened. 

“Are there opportunities to set aside for any of the minority contractors or people that are going to be working on this project so that there’s some revenue flowing into Englewood for the people that live there?” she asked. 

When asked about this after the meeting, Williams said she thought Taylor was worried about gentrification, but also did not know exactly how a housing development would practically work within the church building. 

“As far as the $18 million, she [Clemens] cited a few different sources, but none of them are guaranteed. We haven’t done the feasibility study,” Williams said. 

O-476-26 unanimously passed, but the project will depend on funding that, as Williams pointed out, is not guaranteed. 

Stephen Zenner
Stephen Zenner
Stephen Zenner is an investigative reporter for the Toledo Free Press.

Related Articles

 

Stay Connected

6,978FansLike
1,921FollowersFollow
8,952FollowersFollow
98SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles