UMAT dinner and 1st amendment freedom

Sylvania – Jewish political scientist and long time activist in support of the Palestinian people, Norman Finkelstein, gave the keynote address during the United Muslims Association of Toledo (UMAT) 30th Annual Dinner. 

Introductions

Attendees gathered in the Franciscan Center, where the dinner was hosted, and before the evening’s events began, an afternoon call to prayer was facilitated by Dr. Mohammed Abusamieh, a rheumatologist.

“As Muslim Americans, we have both an opportunity and a responsibility to make our voices heard, but also to build bridges of understanding, and also to stand for justice, compassion, and human dignity,” said Nadeem M. Khan, the master of ceremonies for the evening. 

Each round table of 10-12 had at its centerpiece a U.S. flag, and guests were encouraged to sit next to people they didn’t know. 

Abdullah Haseeb, went to the podium, and in front of the few hundred people in attendance, recited from the Quran and translated. 

Afterwards, Dr. S. Maseeh Rehman, the president of UMAT and an allergist/immunologist, spoke about the history of UMAT and the mission and goals of the dinner. 

A video from Michigan senatorial candidate Abdul El-Sayed. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

History of UMAT dinner

“This is a welcoming city, a city that accommodates, makes everybody feel at home, and we are proud members of this community,” he said. 

“For us, there are at least 35 different nationalities who live here [in Greater Toledo], and the idea of the organization [UMAT] was to connect with them,” he said. “They have different languages, they have different culture, they have different traditions, they have different cuisine. We got to know them, to know each other, to connect each other, and then to work for the betterment of this of the city, of the town, and of the country.”

The other objective Rehman mentioned was to reach out to their non-Muslim friends, so they can know Muslim traditions, values and culture. 

“We have to take responsibilities. We have to define ourselves rather than others,” Rehman said, and added that media and politicians had put forth a false and incorrect image of Muslims. 

“God created us equal. God created us so that we can live in peace, and this is an election year. This is midterm elections going on, and the voting has already started,” Rehman said. 

Rehman talked of the importance of civic engagement for the community. Members of both the Republican and Democratic parties were present to give their respective pitches to the attendees. UMAT said they seek to remain neutral, but wanted to provide a space for open discussion.

“What do we stand for, Muslims? We stand for peace. Islam, Muslim, salaam is peace. We stand for peace, and we will work with anybody and anyone who believes in peace, who believes in justice, who believes in equality, and who believes in harmony.”

Lucas County Commissioner Pete Gerken spoke briefly about observing UMAT over the years as a politician. “Never have I seen an organization over 30 years conduct themselves in the way UMAT has done through many crises and many challenges,” Gerken said, and added that UMAT weathered those crises with courage, kindness, honor, dignity and fearlessness. 

Gerken noted that he had tried to represent Muslims with his position and power and spoke of Lucas County divesting from Israel, a development that happened in August of this year. 

Nadeem Khan acts as master of ceremonies during the dinner. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

Keynote address

Norman Finkelstein was introduced, and he began by saying “Time is limited,” revealing that the organizers of the UMAT dinner had asked him to give an uplifting call-to-action speech. But the academic instead opted for a more sober look at where the United States stood on the issues of Israel and Palestine. 

“We should acknowledge it’s dire, and hopefully people will act, notwithstanding the fact that it’s dire,” he said, describing the Israel-Palestine conflict as half empty and half full at the same time. 

Girl looks at camera, while Dr. Mohammed Abusamieh, a rheumatologist, leads by example in the call to afternoon prayer. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

Empty

Beginning with the empty side of things, Finkelstein brought the crowd to 2024, and spoke of the assault on freedom of speech in the U.S. Speaking of the college encampments, he said it was a hopeful moment that kept the question of Gaza alive, but that those efforts across academia to bring consideration to Gaza were successfully crushed.

Retaliations against speaking about Gaza came in the form of stopping students from attending graduation, suspensions, expulsions, kidnapping non-citizen students and the firing of faculty. 

This was similar, he said, to the “significant repression in academia” during the McCarthy era of the 1950s, but said the 2024 political climate was worse than McCarthyism. 

The evidence he pointed to were the three university presidents who were fired on account of the encampments: the presidents of Harvard, the University of Pennsylvania, and Columbia University. 

Stressing the repression against freedom of speech, he mentioned that Harvard and Columbia both cracked down on the speech about Gaza, using police force, but that this measure did not satisfy the climate enough for the presidents to keep their jobs. 

“That’s without precedent in our history. You cannot name a single era of repression where three presidents of college universities were ousted from office,” Finkelstein said. 

Turning to the crackdowns on students, he emphasized the violence used against them, and asked what reason for this crackdown was. 

Exercising their first amendment rights was deemed extreme in this case, he said, because “it made the Jewish students on campus feel unsafe, unwelcome, and uncomfortable.”

S. Maseeh Rehman, the UMAT President. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

First amendment refresher

Speaking of the U.S. system as particularly impressive in its freedom of speech, Finkelstein explained the fullness of the right. 

“In the United States, you are allowed to agitate for the violent overthrow of the government. That’s a right that the Supreme Court has declared. You have that right,” he said.

“The only time you can’t do it is when the speech comes so close to actual violence. When it comes so close to actual violence, then you’re attempting to overthrow the government. At that point, the government has the right to stop you.”

Emphasizing this point, he said in the U.S., people have the legal right to burn the flag. 

“Our court ruled that if you burn an American flag, you’re trying to make a statement about aspects of our government or our country that you don’t like,” he said. “Since you’re actually using the burning of the flag to make a statement, it’s protected speech in the United States.”

Tension is a deep part of what it means to be an American citizen, Finkelstein argued, as he brought up William Rehnquist, the chief justice of the Supreme Court during the ruling on the burning of the flag. Rehnquist disagreed with the majority ruling on the matter.

“But the majority on the court says, even if it hurts your feelings, even if it pains you, even if it torments you, even if you are anguished and agonized by it, this is America. You have that right of freedom of speech up until the point where violence seems imminent and unavoidable,” Finkelstein said. 

Dave Fournier, democratic candidate for Ohio House’s 44th District, speaks with Pete Gerken, Lucas County Commissioner, while Erin Kramer, Toledo City Council Member At-Large, also socializes during the UMAT dinner. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

Encampments vs. other controversies 

Finkelstein, a Jewish son of Holocaust survivors, brought up the point that many individuals in the Gaza encampments were also Jewish.

“A large number of the students in the encampments were Jewish. That’s just a fact,” he said, and noted that one organization that was suspended for antisemitism was Jewish Voices for Peace.

“The reason I mentioned William Rehnquist’s dissent is that many things in colleges make students feel unsafe, unwelcome, and uncomfortable. That doesn’t mean you have the right to suppress speech on those grounds,” he said. 

Drawing from his experience in academia, Finkelstein mentioned that, by-in-large, Catholics from Latin America are vehemently against abortion. “They have very strong opinions about abortion being murder,” he said. “Does that mean a teacher, a professor, doesn’t have the right to say, ‘I think women should have the right to abortion.’ No.”

Finkelstein added that in colleges and universities, people must make peace with the reality that they will be opened up to points of view that will deeply offend them, “just like burning the American flag deeply offended the chief justice on the Supreme Court.”

Nabil Shaheen, an organizer of the dinner, helps with dinner logistics. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

Situational exceptions

After making a strong argument in favor of speech that may upset listeners, Finkelstein then put parameters on it. 

Drawing up a hypothetical, not too far removed from U.S. history, he had attendees imagine a lone Black student in a class where the teacher was teaching about the genetic inferiority of Black people. 

Being in that situation, “Does it mentally paralyze you, such that you can’t learn anymore?” he asked. “There’s a question; it’s a fair question. Can there be points at which the language becomes so oppressive that it makes it impossible for the student to learn?” He asked the attendees to consider, and expressed that it was a complicated question to unravel. 

Pushing back on the consideration he just made, Finkelstein said he did not believe the instances of the encampments were close to a debilitating level of discomfort for Jewish students. 

“97 percent of the encampments there was no violence whatsoever,” he said, and then said that the violence for the three percent was often caused by outside agitators, like at the University of California Los Angeles (UCLA). 

Finkelstein receives the 2026 UMAT award from Dr. S. Zaheer Hasan, a neurologist, after Finkelstein gave the keynote address. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

Half full

In Finkelstein’s retelling of the suppression of speech around Gaza, he said Jewish students complained of antisemitism, then the “Jewish supremacist billionaire class” threatened to pull funds from the universities. Les Wexner, Ken Griffin and Bill Ackman all threatened to pull contributions that would cost millions of dollars if the encampments were not dealt with on campuses. 

“It was just blackmail,” Finkelstein said, and explained how the backlash against supporters of Gaza echoed through other professional fields as well. 

Ultimately, he said, the Palestinian narrative made its way into the political arena where it changed from suppression into a galvanizing force for electoral politics. 

“Kind of a miracle happened,” he said. “Three years ago, if you had a plank supporting Gaza on your political platform, your ship was sunk.”

“Now there are many campaigns across the country, where a platform supporting Gaza, it not only doesn’t sink your ship, it buoys your ship, it lifts it,” Finkelstein said, and referred to Zohran Mamdani, the mayor of New York City, and senatorial candidate Abdul El-Sayed, as examples of support for Gaza helping candidates. 

“It’s become a real possibility to elect a lot of candidates now taking a principled position on what’s happening in Gaza and elsewhere in the Middle East?” he said. 

Attendees eat after hearing the keynote speaker, Norman Finkelstein, and political pitches from many local politicians. (TFP photo by Stephen Zenner)

The other half

Finkelstein said it has become evident through Mamdani’s successes and failures that it is not enough to be elected. Rather, the coalition Mamdani organized when he ran for mayor needed to remain active to resist the pressure from the powers of the status quo in politics. 

Without an active group resisting what Finkelstein estimated to be the top 20 percent holding the wealth, change in the middle east and Palestine was not possible.

After speaking, Finkelstein began shaking hands and signing his latest book, Gaza’s Gravediggers, after receiving an award from UMAT. 

The last barrier to people eating the dinner was an onslaught of presentations from local politicians.

Derek Merrin, running for Ohio’s 9th Congressional District, spoke, and a video of Abdul El-Sayed addressing attendees of the dinner played.

When Rehman was asked how he felt about both candidates for Ohio’s 9th Congressional District not calling what is going on in Gaza a genocide, he admitted, “Yes. We are disappointed that this is not being addressed, but that’s what I say to everybody. That doesn’t mean that you should get discouraged. Your vote— it’s a civic obligation. Go and vote. Go and express yourself,” he said. 

“Go and say what you believe in, and don’t get discouraged. We live in America. You know, a time will come when people will listen to you. Three years ago, we could not talk what we are talking today.”

Stephen Zenner
Stephen Zenner
Stephen Zenner is an investigative reporter for the Toledo Free Press.

Related Articles

 

Stay Connected

6,978FansLike
1,921FollowersFollow
8,952FollowersFollow
98SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles