TOLEDO – A contemplative conversation took place at this week’s agenda review surrounding the hot topic of Flock Group, Inc.’s automated license plate reader cameras (ALPRs).
Fewer people were in attendance, allowing council members to speak in a more relaxed manner.

Legislated police guidelines
What prompted this discussion was one of the last items on the agenda, TMP-13004, proposed by Councilman Adam Martinez, District 2, which in its early legislative phase, sought to codify restrictions to Toledo Police Department (TPD) technology.
There are three main parts to the proposed ordinance that is still in process:
1. Restricting data regarding reproductive healthcare use, gender-affirming care, and immigration status, and also not being willing to share such data with any other law enforcement agency.
2. Decreeing that TPD “develop internal policy to prevent the use of emerging technologies to stalk, harass, racially profile, or otherwise retaliate against citizens,” and the consequences for violation of such a policy will be termination.
3. TPD will hold monthly reviews of data sharing of Flock, and manually remove 287(g) affiliated departments/agencies.
Martinez noted that about 11 percent of TPD’s shared users have a 287(g) agreement, a designation that allows local law enforcement to assist in immigration enforcement.
Seemingly confident in the restrictions on Flock, Martinez said, “They have the anti-immigration filter set ‘off,’ so nobody can redo it regardless. So that was kind of a failsafe, but I think it was missing the spirit of the law, so that [his new legislation] addresses that portion.
“I am open to co-sponsors on this…I’d like to vote on November 4, but I’m fine with this going to the committee if you wanted to address it specifically,” he said.

Council discourse
No one outright said they would co-sponsor, but President of Toledo City Council and representative for District 4, Vanice Williams, agreed that safeguards need to be in place for the technology.
Much of the discussion seemed to, like other meetings, be based around waiting for the results of the audit, being performed by John Rivalsky, the Toledo city auditor.
Updating members on the progress of the audit, Williams mentioned that Rivalsky had run into problems getting access to Flock data, because he needed some sort of law enforcement credentials.
“He is still compiling it right now,” she said. “I’ll know more Monday if he’ll have it available on Wednesday [Nov. 4].”
Speaking to the uncertainty around what may happen with the Flock system, as votes come up in the next week, Mac Driscoll, at-large councilman, thought the resolution was a step in the right direction to, at the very least, reign in some of the uses of the Flock system.
But Driscoll was less confident in the safeguards implemented by Flock and/or the city to prevent abuse.
“I just hope everybody knows when you go to do a search in Flock, you get to type in what you want, so it’s not that hard to just lie,” Driscoll said.
Visibly perturbed by Driscoll’s response, Martinez waited until after District 5 Council Member Sam Melden and Williams spoke their peace into the discourse, and then corrected Driscoll.
“It has to be [an] FBI educated crime that you’re looking for specifically,” Martinez said, alluding to a claim that he had made at last week’s council meeting about Flock getting rid of their write-in search function, swapping it for a drop-down menu with limited, standardized categories modeled after the FBI’s 52 classifications for crime.
While more secure than an open search, Driscoll’s point about lying is not necessarily curbed, and most criticism of Flock revolves around the power of the system, assuming that even under the best set of guardrails, contingencies can break down.
When the Flock representative, Trevor Chandler, the director of public relations for Flock, visited Toledo in June 2026, he said that since 2025, searches in Flock must fall into the National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS), creating more transparency.
Data policy
Melden made reference to an ordinance he was working on that was meant to regulate how the city used data and Artificial Intelligence (AI) that would eventually be extended to Flock.
“I mentioned that we should have soon a data governance and data privacy policy to look at,” Melden said, but mentioned that the legislation had gotten caught up in bureaucratic back-and-forth over the language used.
Williams seconded the efforts of Martinez and Melden, and drew attention to zoning email scams that were taking advantage of Toledoans.
“If you get that email, please call our zoning department, call Engage Toledo, call whoever. We would not tell you to pay through an email,” she said.
Protecting speech
Taking some of the feedback from the last committee meeting, Martinez referenced a woman who was concerned about surveillance being used to monitor people for their religious or political beliefs.
“I want to make sure that we’re protecting our ability to protest and our civil liberties,” Martinez said, admitting that the safeguards were a work in progress.
Areas like schools, places of worship, libraries, hospitals, community centers, and where unions meet, he said, should be given special consideration in relation to where the cameras are placed. His working solution was to “geofence” or create a perimeter around sensitive locations, where TPD would not have surveillance technology.
Martinez opened up the floor for others in attendance to weigh in on this idea.
Melden and Theresa Morris, councilwoman for District 6, raised questions about the legality of imposing these new restrictions on Flock, which signed a contract with the city for 2025-2028.
“I’ll put up a referral for legal to see at what point are we nullifying our contract,” Morris said.











