TOLEDO – Another Toledo City Council meeting was dominated by a divided council on the issue of Flock Group, Inc.’s automated license plate reader (ALPR) cameras.
A Flock resolution for council
When Resolution 435-26, a resolution asking for the city and mayor to cease their contract with Flock, came up for a vote, Cerssandra McPherson, councilwoman at-large, proposed to hold the resolution for another two weeks, until after the audit of the Flock system was completed.
When Resolution 435-26 came up for a vote during the last council meeting, McPherson asked to hold the resolution then as well. At that time, the resolution had only been read once, and so was subject to different voting rules, requiring nine votes to supersede the second reading with a vote – votes the anti-Flock council members did not have.
A brief rehashing of some of the same points that had been made at previous city council committees, reviews and meetings were restated.
McPherson wanted to look at the audit before voting to shut down the cameras. Instead of a ban, Councilman Adam Martinez of District 2, proposed restrictions on Flock’s cameras in O-460-26, which was put into committee during the meeting.
The original adversary of Flock on council, At-Large Council Member Nick Komives, felt a duty to act with the will of the people, as Flock cameras had become increasingly unpopular.
President of Council, Vanice Williams of District 4, gave an update on John Rivalsky’s audit of the Flock system, telling the council that Rivalsky required 30 days to complete the audit due to permissions that took time for Rivalsky to receive.
Theresa Gadus, District 3, pointed out that holding the resolution for two weeks would not give Rivalsky 30 days to complete the audit. Last council meeting, Gadus doubted the timeline for the completion of Rivalsky’s audit, citing the massive amount of data the cameras have collected since 2022 when they were installed.
“I don’t think that our auditor is going to be able to do that in 30 days,” she said during the Oct. 20 meeting. At that time, the contingency seeking to wait for the audit before a vote on R-435-26 asked for a delay until Nov. 4, and also 30 days for the audit to be completed, without an understanding of how those two separate timelines would converge.
Williams asked for clarification on getting rid of the whole Flock system or just the ALPRs, and said she was opposed to getting rid of all of the Flock system.
District 5 Council Member Sam Melden then pressed Council to make a decision and vote on the resolutions.
“I hope that every time Flock comes up, we don’t turn into a mini committee hearing about all of it,” he said. “We only have one job; it’s to say ‘yes’ or to say ‘no.’ And now we’re talking about how our auditor doesn’t have a credential that he needs to get to the bottom of the details. This notion of the audit being the key to unlocking what we think [about Flock], I don’t buy it.”
The resolution, Melden said, was to show where Council stood on the issue of Flock and how each member was representing their constituents; he felt Council had enough information to vote.
McPherson clarified that she needed the information from the audit for her to make an informed decision. “It’s not a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ when I don’t know, and I don’t have all of the information,” she said.

Motion and vote
Council took a vote on the motion to hold R-435-26, which needed seven votes to hold it.
- “Yes,” to hold: George Sarantou, Williams, John Hobbs III, Martinez, McPherson, Theresa Morris
- “No,” to hold: Driscoll, Gadus, Komives, Erin Kramer, Melden
Since the motion to hold only got six votes, Council took a vote on R-435-26. The results were:
- “Yes” to support the resolution: Driscoll, Gadus, Komives, Kramer, Melden
- “No” to the resolution: Sarantou, Williams, Hobbs, Martinez, McPherson, Morris
Resolution 435-26 failed.

People’s resolve
After the resolution failed, a group of about 40 anti-Flock activists left the Council chambers and began processing the results with one another.
One privacy-minded individual who gave the alias “Metro” asked why Council needed data from the Flock audit at this point, when Council passed funding to purchase the Flock system without knowing specifics on the technology years ago.
Abriendo Puertas para Soluciones’ (APPS) Advocacy Chair, Jessica Molina, organized the majority of anti-Flock sentiment, and said they would initiate a ballot measure.
When asked what got her into this attentive position against Flock she said, “Once we started reading and figuring out the privacy concerns, the data sharing governance concerns, then it just turned into something bigger.
“And now…these Council members are not being representative of their constituents, and so I think the longer that it goes on, the more the tension actually builds. And the reasons to bring the Flock cameras down, they just keep getting larger because more people keep hearing about it and more people want them down.”

Resurrection of R-435-26
While the activists were convening in the foyer of 1 Government Center, the one absent council member, Brittany Jones (at-large), entered the Council chambers and asked for R-435-26 to be put back into play.
“I would like to put a motion for reconsideration of the resolution [R-435-26]… Anyone that would want to put it back up for vote, I would really appreciate that motion,” Jones said.
Williams told Jones someone who voted against the resolution would have to make the motion.
“I was so moved to recommend so that she could vote,” McPherson said.
Martinez moved to put the resolution in committee, and Driscoll moved to relieve the resolution from committee.
Seven votes were needed for R-435-26 to come out of committee. With Jones’ vote, the council stood at six votes for pulling the resolution out of committee and six votes against pulling the resolution out of committee.
“The mayor can break it, but he’s not here today,” Williams said. “So we’ll send it to him to take it out of committee.”
The Toledo Free Press reached out to Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz for comment, and did not hear back by the publishing of this article.

First read on Toledo Police restrictions
Another legislation dealing with Flock was presented by Martinez – O-460-26 – which stated three restrictions on the Toledo Police Department’s use of technology.
- No sharing data dealing with “reproductive healthcare use, gender-affirming care, and immigration status…”
- Prohibited use of technology to “stalk, harass, racially profile, retaliate against any individual…”
- TPD will manually remove any sharing with a department with 287 (g) immigration enforcement authorization.
Martinez himself moved for the ordinance to be read once and moved to committee for public comment and review.

Also during the meeting:
R-452-26 – James Hartung was memorialized.
R-453-26 – The President of the Hungarian Club of Toledo, Peter Ujvagi, commemorated the 70th Anniversary of the Hungarian Revolution of 1956.

A-454-26 – David Mann was re-appointed for a three-year term to the Toledo Community Improvement Corporation (TCIC).
O-413-26 – $713,106 of American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds were reallocated to the Municipal Recovery Revenue Replacement project. $502,297 was reallocated from the Food System Hub and Grocery Store Construction Incentive projects. $210,809 came from Central ARPA Administration.
O-425-26 – Originally funded through ARPA, Toledo’s General Fund will provide $355,297 to support a new round of participating neighborhood markets for the Healthy Food Small Market Program.
O-457-26 – $80,000 to warming centers through the Code Blue Cold Weather Response Initiative.
O-464-26 – $40,000 to TARTA for their Youth Summer Blast Pass program, where children ride TARTA for free.

Firefighters
A handful of firefighters were seen at the meeting, including union Local 92 President Joe Cira.
Last week during the Finance, Budget and Debt Committee meeting, Cira asked people to vote “yes” on Issue 16 to fund the Toledo Fire & Rescue services. There are no hard figures on how many layoffs the fire department may face, so Cira and other firefighters were keeping an eye on expenses in City Council and watching for anything that might concern them.
“If there’s gonna be a bunch of layoffs, I need to know,” Cira said. Throughout the meeting Cira estimated about $800,000 had been spent, and said that amounted to about seven firefighters.
Even without layoffs, Cira said the firefighters would start with less firefighters than the year before, because of retirements.
Sarantou said he didn’t know what the layoffs would look like and was waiting on those exact figures from the administration.
The administration guided the Toledo Free Press to the unspecific list that was given during the last Finance, Budget and Debt Committee meeting, and said more hard figures would be available on Nov. 15.












