TOLEDO – A moderate amount of support followed a Toledo City Council meeting where a resolution opposing Flock Group, Inc.’s automated license plate reader (ALPR) technology was held until the next meeting, on November 4.
Before the controversial moment, the council acknowledged Toledo Police Department (TPD) Chief Mike Troendle’s retirement and the Toledo Area Regional Transit Authority’s (TARTA’s) 55 year anniversary.
Troendle and the man to take his place, Assistant Chief Kevin Braun, waited in the back of the council meeting until resolution 435-26 – the resolution urging the city to terminate their agreement with Flock – was decided for the day.

Suspend for info
Fairly early into the meeting At-Large Councilwoman Cerssandra McPherson made a motion to suspend or hold resolution 435-26 until after the independent audit of TPD’s Flock was completed.
“I would ask that we hold this resolution…because Council has approved an audit of the Flock cameras, and we have yet to receive the audit,” she said. “I would like to see that data, that audit, before I put forth my ‘yes’ or ‘no’ on Flock cameras.”
This motion caused an active dispute during the meeting.
After McPherson, President of Council and Councilwoman for District 4, Vanice Williams, weighed into the conversation in support of McPherson’s motion.
“Why are we pausing it? What reason are we pausing it?” she asked. Without the data, Williams said she had major reservations for how TPD would be able to operate within the restricted budget for police, especially if the levy for additional police officers did not pass.
“If we take another tool away from the police officers as well as [funding to train more] police officers, where will that lead the safety of the city?” Williams asked her fellow council members to consider.
Last week, members of Council had the opportunity to meet with someone from Flock. Williams said she met with Flock and the individual performing the audit of Flock’s Toledo data, and she emphasized due diligence in the democratic process.

Will of the people
But the original never-Flock representative, At-Large Council Member Nick Komives, countered both council members’ ask to wait for the audit by saying that the people had already asked for Flock to be paused.
“I think that the public has been more than clear in their stance on this issue, and I don’t think that it could be more clear,” Komives said, and pointed out that many people waited two hours to speak at a committee hearing with most all public speakers opposing Flock.
“The first time that we voted on Flock, I was the lone no vote,” he said, and pointed to the four co-sponsors of the resolution who had gone from supporting Flock to calling for Flock’s contract to be terminated. Over time, Komives was confident that more problems with mass-surveillance would surface, and called for a vote on the resolution that day.
Furthermore, he said the safeguards with Flock to guarantee security, confidentiality and reliability were the responsibility of Flock, and should not have been the responsibility of council.
District 5 Council Member Sam Melden said pausing Flock was an interim step we could take to be cautious about abuses of the ALPR system.
“It reminds me a little bit of like, if I went and got blood work done to see if I was allergic to something or see if I was having a physical reaction to something, while I was waiting for the results, it wouldn’t be a terrible idea for me to stop eating it just to wait and see,” he said.
Reminding his fellow council members that this was a resolution, not binding legislation, Mac Driscoll (At-Large) said there shouldn’t be a hesitation to vote on the resolution.
“We are not tearing down cameras with this vote,” Driscoll said, pointing out that the 435 resolution was just asking the police chief and mayor to cancel their cooperation with Flock.
Tuesday’s vote, Driscoll said, was just “signaling our opinion,” and in light of the public outcry, Driscoll said it would be smart to vote to acknowledge constituents of Toledo.

Political theater
Making waves in City Council, Adam Martinez, District 2, agreed the vote was symbolic, but added that it was a “waste of the constituents’ time.”
Regardless of the outcome of the vote, Martinez said, “nothing changes.”
In light of the symbolic nature of the resolution, Martinez argued that the resolution would make the council look ineffective.
“…this is actually kind of embarrassing that we have to do it this way versus legislating and putting up ordinances that actually make a difference to make our communities safer,” he said.
Legislation dealing with Flock was forthcoming, he promised, and said, “At some point, there has to be a base level of trust with the administration, [with] TPD, a healthy trust of the community, and making sure that we find the common ground. And I think it is premature to put legislation before the audit comes back.” Ending his time, Martinez called the resolution “folly.”
Williams reminded the council members that there was a motion to hold or vote on the resolution.
Clarifying her stance, McPherson said she wanted to see what was happening in Toledo specifically. McPherson said she had heard about the abuses of Flock, but warned, “I need to know if it’s happening here in the City of Toledo,” she said, asking for time to see the audit.
Part of what she proposed were safeguards to the system, asking for more information to know how to appropriately deal with the Flock system.
Directly responding to Martinez, Komives emphasized the importance of the resolution.
Turning towards the public seating in the room he said, “The whole point of this is that we are listening,” Komives said. “This is only being brought forward because you requested it, because you asked us to do this, because you sent us thousands of emails, because you have posted all over social media, because you have come out to events.
“So I don’t want you to hear from some of my colleagues who are saying that this is all folly. This is all show,” he said.
Referring to the vote on the audit, Councilman George Sarantou (At-Large) reminded everyone that the desire to audit the system was passed unanimously. He questioned why they had voted if they were not going to wait to hear back from it.

Discussion of data
Another direct response to Martinez’s claims of show and political theater, District 3 Council Member Theresa Gadus said, “Supporting residents is not theater.”
Gadus pushed back with quiet frustration. “To address my Councilwoman’s concern [McPherson], we would have data if my FOIA was answered over 100 days ago.”
At this quip, the room erupted in applause, which Williams responded to with bangs of her gavel and threatened to have attendees removed if they did not quiet down.
“I’m willing to do whatever I have to do so that I can see the information, so I can defend my residents,” Gadus said.
After Gadus was finished, Williams said the audit would be finished Nov. 4.
“I’m fearful for my district and the crime that we have,” Williams said, explaining her position in support of Flock. “I’ve talked to the mother who lost her baby. I’ve talked to the mother that lost their son,” she said, highlighting how personally she took the decision.
Then she referred to the motion to hold or vote on the resolution.
“We have had these cameras in place since 2022,” Gadus said, pushing back on the idea that the audit would be done in early November. “It’s four years. That’s four years of data.”
“I don’t think that our auditor is going to be able to do that in 30 days,” she said. “I just don’t think that’s a realistic goal to go over all of that information to look at trends over time. It’s one thing to look at one month, but to look at trends over time, that is going to take a long time.”

Vote
Reclaiming the time before anyone could speak again, Williams asked Julie Gibbons, the clerk of city council, to explain the suspension motion, to hold or to vote on the resolution.
Voting “yes” would mean a desire to vote on the resolution that day, while voting “no” would hold it until the next council meeting.
At the end of the vote the “Yeses” included: Driscoll, Melden, Erin Kramer (At-Large), John Hobbs III (District 1), Gadus, Brittany Jones (At-Large), and Komives.
The “Nos” were: Martinez, Theresa Morris (District 6), Williams, Sarantou, and McPherson.
Since this was a vote for the second reading of the resolution, the “yeses” needed nine instead of the seven they got.
Once the vote was concluded, the chiefs of police exited the room along with anti-Flock protesters, essentially emptying the City Council chambers.

Anti-Flock movement
Outside in the foyer of 1 Government Center, Sean Nestor, an activist with an anti-Flock stance and a board president of the Toledo Free Press, talked with about 20 people.
“If a problem happens in Toledo, that’s one thing, but it hasn’t happened in Toledo. And sure, it’s happening in all these other places with the same technology, but that’s them. We’re different. This is a completely faulty line of reasoning,” he said.
Encouraging his fellow anti-Flock participants, he told them not to be discouraged, because politicians are motivated by a combination of factors. Expecting setbacks like this, Nestor told those who had showed up to keep the pressure on.
Different members in the circle appreciated the words of Komives, talking about Flock as a faulty product, and the tidbit from Gadus about the TPD records request going unanswered for 100 days.
“If I had a subcontractor that responded in that manner, they would be replaced,” said Fred Newstead, a construction superintendent.
Most members were in silent agreement, and spoke about making the council more accountable to voters.
“We’ve made progress,” Nestor said. “As Nick [Komives] said, when he first did this, he was the only ‘no’ vote,” and now the anti-Flock protesters roughly counted about six members faithfully voting against Flock for the time being.
Protesters mentioned a citizen’s initiative against the Flock ALPR readers, but said they were still working on the language for the proposal.

Safeguards
After the meeting, Martinez talked to the press about ordinances he was working on to improve safeguards with the Flock system, and also mentioned the meeting with Flock representatives was fruitful.
“I still think we’re in our infancy with this type of technology,” he admitted. “I still think we’re learning and we’re growing, and we want to make sure that there’s all kinds of different guardrails because nobody should feel unsafe in our city for whatever reason.”
During a hearing on Flock in June, Council Member Gadus had asked Assistant Chief Braun if the City of Toledo’s Flock cameras had been used in any sort of immigration enforcement actions, and Braun pivoted to the Public Relations Director of Flock, Trevor Chandler, who did not give an answer to this question.
The Toledo Free Press mentioned having reached out to Chandler for an answer specifically to this question, without hearing back.
Martinez answered that he was not there for that specific hearing, in June, but elaborated on the new safeguards that no longer allow officers to write-in reasons for their searches, no longer allow searches for immigration or abortion and require a case number associated with every search. Martinez also expressed a base-level trust in TPD.
While not full-proof, Martinez felt there were actions that could be taken to help the technology be effective for police use, while not allowing for rampant abuses of the system.












