MONROE, MICH. – When the rain started, Zella Hoath ran outside.
She convinced a group of other women to run out and dance in it with her. At Women’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility, it has become a story people tell.
“That sense of joy in the most depressing of places was something she could bring,” said Christine Hume, the Eastern Michigan University professor who advises the College in Prison Writing Club, where Hoath was a member.
Hoath never missed a meeting.
That spirit now hangs in a gallery. Scarred Identity, an exhibit of poems, audio recordings and ‘zines by the club’s members, is now on display through Nov. 2 at the Immaculate Heart of Mary Sisters Motherhouse Gallery in Monroe, Mich. The writers are incarcerated at Women’s Huron Valley, Michigan’s only women’s prison.

The show asks visitors to meet its writers as people before they meet the label their crimes gave them.
“A real person, not the six-digit monster my crime paints me as,” wrote club member Angela Fisher, when asked what she hopes people take away from the show.
Hoath didn’t live to see it open. She died in June, days after drawing a small smiley face beside her name at her last writing club meeting, as she did at every one. The club dedicated the exhibit to her.
Her death came during a painful stretch at the prison. She was one of five women who died at Women’s Huron Valley between mid-May and late July, months after a state House hearing on the conditions there, including mold and medical care. The deaths drew an investigation by the Michigan Department of Corrections and calls from about 30 lawmakers for the department’s director to resign.
To the women who wrote beside her, she was never just a headline.
“Zella was the shining light in our dark world,” wrote fellow member Stevie Marie.
“Zella was kindred, my best friend,” wrote Heather McKee. “She held that space for everybody. She never judged.”

The club grew out of EMU’s College in Prison program. Students earn full bachelor’s degrees, taught by the same faculty who teach on the main campus. The program began in fall 2023 with 22 students and now has 70. EMU says it is the first and only public four-year university serving incarcerated women.
Students there started the writing club two years ago. It began with room for 18, though interest far outpaced that, and it now has about 33 members.
The exhibit came to the club through the nonprofit YpsiWrites. Over about three months this summer, members chose a title, wrote an artist statement, workshopped poems, recorded audio and made ‘zines. The work had to be approved by MDOC before it could be exhibited.
They built the title from two ideas. “One was scars, and the other was identity,” Hume said.
Hume put it this way: “People who think that poetry is dead should visit prisons, because in prison it is alive and thriving.”
“Every human is one choice, one scar, one scenario that could lead them to prison,” wrote member Amber Martens. Others described what the club has given them.
“Being part of the writing club meant an avenue of expression unspoken,” wrote Lilly Xiong. Brandi Wentworth, who spent her career in accounting, wrote that the club “opened up a new passion for me in my 50s” and that she now finds her “world surrounded with words.”
Research on prison education points the same direction. A 2013 RAND Corporation analysis of earlier studies found that people who took part in correctional education had 43 percent lower odds of returning to prison. A separate RAND research brief estimated that every dollar spent on such programs saved four to five dollars in reincarceration costs.

Hume remembers Hoath as quiet in the club, until she read her work aloud. “There was silence, because she could really hold the room with her words,” Hume said.
The club made a tribute book for her. At the opening, five recently released students read pieces mostly written by classmates still inside. Hoath’s daughter was there too.
About 80 percent of the students are mothers, Hume said. Megan Lechner, who directs EMU’s College in Prison program, doesn’t dodge what brought them there.
“Certainly, some of our students have done harm. We can’t deny that,” Lechner said. “But what we do want folks to see is that we are all more than our one mistake.”
The exhibit will move to EMU’s campus next, Hume said, and Lansing is a possibility.
Wherever it goes, it will carry her dedication, and the story of the woman who ran out into the rain.
Scarred Identity is on display through Nov. 2 at the Immaculate Heart of Mary Sisters Motherhouse Gallery, 610 W. Elm Ave., Monroe.











