Waterville Township hears input on LED billboards

WATERVILLE TOWNSHIP – In public meetings and online, Anthony Wayne area residents pretty much all share the same opinion about allowing electronic billboards along U.S. 24 in Waterville Township, and that would be a resounding “No thanks.”

“It’s like a giant TV that you’re going to put up in someone’s back yard,” said resident Dave Schmidt during an Oct. 15 public hearing about the proposed change. “I don’t see where it’s benefitting our township.”

Whitehouse resident Leslie Harper and 17-year-old Notre Dame Academy student Madeline Jeffer read statistics showing higher crash rates around electronic billboards. And Monclova Township resident Lyn Cox wore a sequined hat that she likened to an LED billboard.

“We’re not in Las Vegas, and we don’t have to start pretending we are,” Cox said.

Township resident Terry Beam asked about an open letter from Waterville Municipal Administrator Jon Gochenour, urging the township to follow the city’s lead and prohibit billboards and off-premise signs in all zoning districts.

Unlike cities, townships cannot impose an outright ban on billboards said John Borell, assistant Lucas County prosecuting attorney. A township only has the authority granted by Ohio law, and Ohio Revised Code 519.20 states that outdoor advertising is classified as a business use and must be permitted in all districts, he said.

With the current wording in the zoning resolution, any business could put up an electronic billboard anywhere, as long as it on a pole with a maximum height of 15 feet and with a maximum face sign of 72 square feet.

Dutch Road Storage, in red, backs up to U.S. 24 in Waterville Township. An off-premise sign on the property would be visible to drivers, and those living in the area – including the 70-unit Waterville Place Apartments being constructed on Kay Drive. (AWFP image by Karen Gerhardinger)

When Dutch Road Storage owners Dan Bollin and Jim Moline looked at getting a variance to have a larger off-premise sign – one that would advertise businesses not located on their site – they found that the application fee is a nonrefundable $10,000, with no guarantee that the Board of Zoning Appeals would even approve it. Several attorneys, including Borell, concurred that the fee is “unreasonable,” so the Zoning Commission began looking at options. 

The proposed new language would allow up to two signs, a maximum height of 25 feet and sign face of 300 square feet, and only along U.S. 24 frontage. If trustees approve the change, this would replace the language allowing the smaller signs anywhere in the township. If trustees vote no, the current language stands, and anyone could apply for a variance for a larger sign. The Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) would determine whether to grant a variance. And if one is approved, that would set a precedent that would require the BZA to approve all others, said Trustee Toby Miller.

“We’re trying to find the best solution under the Ohio Revised Code. With this, we can control the size, offsets and location,” he said. 

Jerry Parker, an attorney with decades of experience representing outdoor advertising, spoke on behalf of Bollin and Moline.

“This is a wonderful resolution because it’s helping the community and the businesses in your community,” Parker said.

A one-page fact sheet he passed out prior to the meeting outlines some of the “Key Facts About Modern LED Billboards.” Advanced technology allows brightness levels to be adjusted automatically depending on ambient lighting conditions. Messages are designed for quick readability. Automation and flashing can be restricted. Having an LED billboard would allow multiple businesses to be promoted in one spot, rather than on multiple sites. And the billboard can be a source of public information, sharing weather and traffic alerts as well as community announcements, Parker said.  

“Transportation studies have not consistently demonstrated that properly designed and regulated LED billboards result in higher accident rates compared to traditional outdoor advertising,” he said, refuting some of the studies shared by opponents. 

Cox noted that, if approved, the off-premise sign could generate up to $54,000 a month in revenue for its owners, and wondered what the township would gain financially. Nothing, said Miller, noting that the township would only receive its share of property taxes based on the value of Dutch Road Storage and the sign itself, not the advertising sold.

After Bollin, Moline and Parker left the meeting, resident Debra Reed jokingly proposed another idea: for the township to put up its own electronic billboard behind the red barn on the Dutch Road property it bought earlier this year, and use it to make $54,000 a month to support the township. She’s been opposed to the billboard for its impact on existing and future residents, including those who will be moving into 70-unit Waterville Loft Apartments right across U.S. 24 from Dutch Road Storage.

Trustees have set their next meeting for Thursday, Oct. 29 at 7:30 p.m. A decision could be made at that time. One factor not yet ironed out is whether a maximum of two billboards means that each would be double-sided – meaning four sign faces – or if one pole holding a double-sided sign would be considered the maximum. Miller noted that, as a legislative action, a decision to change the zoning resolution could be subject to citizens’ referendum. 

During the meeting, the trustees also took comments from residents about a proposed change to the zoning resolution to add M-3 zoning for data centers and large industrial projects. A citizens group has been working with the township for 11 months to come up with a final change to govern data centers, before a moratorium expires at the end of the year. If approved on Oct. 29, it would go into effect a month later.

Cox suggested that the trustees hold off and look into adding that any facility using more than 25 megawatts of power a month be classified as industrial and placed into M-3. She also urged trustees to learn more from industry experts Tammy Clark, Kristen Kelly and Stephen Petty, who spoke during a recent data center symposium. 

“Further work is being done and I encourage you to pump the brakes and do your due diligence,” she said. “Just because you’ve put a lot of time into it doesn’t mean it’s done.”

Miller said putting the new data center language in the books doesn’t mean that further revisions could be done later. 

Residents also urged Trustee Kyle Hertzfeld to make sure he was able to vote on the data center language along with Miller and Trustee Julie Theroux. Originally, Hertzfeld thought he might have a conflict of interest because another Hertzfeld family – a distant relative – lives in an area being considered for a data center. After checking with the Ohio Attorney General and Ohio Ethics Commission, as well as two attorneys, Hertzfeld found there is no conflict and he no longer plans to recuse himself.

Karen Gerhardinger
Karen Gerhardinger
Karen Gerhardinger is a freelance journalist with a passion for sharing the stories of communities - including schools, local government and nonprofit organizations. An Anthony Wayne High School graduate, Karen earned a bachelor's degree in journalism from the University of Texas at Arlington. Her career has included positions with The Fort Worth Star-Telegram, The Columbus Dispatch and The Mirror Newspaper. To share story ideas, email [email protected].

Related Articles

 

Stay Connected

6,978FansLike
1,921FollowersFollow
8,952FollowersFollow
98SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles